Quick Summary
- A few weeks after I resigned from my old job, someone from my old workplace joked that, since I wasn’t visiting anymore, I apparently wasn’t willing to show my face there. The assumption underneath was that silence meant something to hide.
- Every group makes a claim on its members, and the size of that claim varies enormously. Some end where the work ends; some extend to your shoes, your holidays and your next career.
- The model: where leaving is rare, leaving is a verdict. An exit from a permanent group reads as a comment on everyone who stays, which is why an explanation gets demanded.
A few weeks after I resigned from my old job back in the day, someone from my old workplace jokingly remarked that, since I was unwilling to visit anymore, I apparently wasn’t willing to show my face there either.
I told her plainly that wasn't the case.
But the remark conveyed to me what it assumed. That a person who leaves without explaining himself must have something to hide.
That silence is a kind of confession. That I owed the building an account, and by not giving one I had defaulted on a debt.
I hadn't thought of it as a debt. I'd thought of it as my life.
The claim a group makes
Here's what I've come to understand about it.
Every group makes a claim on its members. That much is unavoidable; belonging to anything means giving it something. What varies, enormously, is the size of the claim.
In the company that we built after I exited my job, the claim ends roughly where the work ends. People do excellent work together, and then they go home and live entirely separate lives.
Nobody knows where a colleague spent the weekend, and nobody would think to ask. When someone leaves, people wish them well and get on with things.
It's not coldness. It's just that the relationship has a shape, and the shape is the work.
The place I left was different. There, the claim reached into almost everything. Where you travelled. What you wore. Which shoes you'd turned up in.
Small things became topics, and topics became discussions, and nothing was too minor to be noticed by somebody.

The sociologist Ferdinand Tönnies drew a distinction, well over a century ago, that describes this exactly.
He contrasted community (Gemeinschaft, which is a German word), where people are bound by shared life and every member's business is in some sense everyone's business, with association (Gesellschaft), where people come together around a purpose and the relationship is bounded by it.
Neither is good or bad in itself. A family is rightly a community. But a workplace that operates like a village carries a village's expectations: that you are known, that you are watched, and that your life is partly common property.
Where leaving is rare, leaving is a verdict
That explains the scrutiny. It doesn't quite explain the demand for an explanation. For that, there's a second piece.
The job I left was one that people very rarely leave. Most people who join stay for the rest of their working lives. So an exit isn't a routine event there; it's something that almost never happens.
And in a group where nobody leaves, leaving says something.
Not because the person leaving intends it to, but because it can't help being read as a comment on the choice everyone else made by staying. If he's going, what does that say about the rest of us?
Where leaving is rare, leaving is a verdict. The demand for an explanation is really a request to be told it wasn't a verdict on those who chose to stay.
Seen that way, the curiosity is less nosy than it looks. Underneath "what is he doing now?" is a quieter question: "was he right to go, and if he was, what does that make us?" An explanation would have answered it.
Silence leaves it hanging, which is uncomfortable, and discomfort tends to fill itself with a story. Hence the face I was apparently unwilling to show.
Notice that this is a trait of the group, not of the individuals in it. Put the same people in an organisation where people come and go every year and the question barely arises.
Exits are normal there, so an exit means nothing in particular.
Who is actually owed an explanation
Which brings me to the question I asked myself. Who is actually owed an explanation when you make a large decision about your own life?
Here's the test I've settled on.
Explanations are owed to the people your decision costs something.
Your family, if your choice changes their security. A partner, if it changes their plans. Your team, if they inherit work or risk because of what you decided.
Clients, if your departure affects what they were promised. Those people have a real stake, and they deserve a real account; clear, early, and honest.
Everyone else is owed courtesy where courtesy is possible: a decent goodbye, a warm word, good wishes in both directions. But not an elaborate explanation.
Sometimes even that simple courtesy becomes difficult when people press for details that any rational person would rather keep private.
Curiosity, however sincere, does not create a claim. Being affected does.
That one distinction has saved me a great deal of energy. It turns out most of the people who most want an explanation are the ones it doesn't belong to, and most of the people who are owed one already have it.
I paid a meaningful amount, in the end, to leave without the long round of explaining. It was the right trade.
But I'd have been spared some second-guessing if I'd had this test clearly in mind at the time, because it would have told me I owed the building nothing beyond a clean, courteous exit.
Designing the size of the claim
Now turn it around, because as a founder this is something you control.
Every company decides, mostly by accident, how large a claim it makes on its people. Some proudly describe themselves as a family. It sounds warm, and sometimes it is.
But a family's claim is enormous. Families get to know where you went on the weekend. Families take it personally when you leave.
Netflix famously took the opposite line in its culture memo, describing itself as a team rather than a family. I think that framing is more honest than it first sounds.
A team asks a great deal of you inside the work, and very little outside it. And a team expects people to move on; leaving is part of how teams work, not a betrayal of them.

That's what we've tried to build. A place where the claim is large inside the work and small outside it.
Where what you wear and where you go are your own business. Where someone who leaves is wished well and doesn't owe the rest of us a speech.
And here's why it matters beyond comfort. Clear, limited claims make clean exits possible, and clean exits compound.
People who leave well speak well of where they were. Some of them refer others. A few come back. Over years, that accumulates into a reputation that no amount of recruitment copy can fake.
A village keeps its people by watching them. A good company keeps its people by deserving them, and lets them go without asking for a report.
As for showing my face: I show it wherever I choose to. That choice is mine to make, not anyone else’s. And I don’t owe an explanation in advance.



